Skip to content

Cookie banners and consent: what to check

Best practices1 min readFixes 2 checks cookie-banner-reject-button, cookie-banner-detected

A consent banner must actually block non-essential cookies until the visitor agrees, and it must not hide the content.

Step by step, with screenshots: Cookie banner requirements: what a compliant banner needs, with examples →

Check your own site

Runs these 2 checks and the other 191, free, in about 45 seconds.

Or run only this check with the free Cookie scanner (GDPR consent).

What it is

A cookie banner is the notice a website shows on the first visit to ask for consent to non-essential cookies and tracking, with buttons to accept, reject or choose categories. In the EU and UK it is required whenever the site uses cookies that are not strictly necessary.

A banner only counts if it works: tracking must wait for the answer, and rejecting must be as easy as accepting. Regulators enforce this; in 2022 France's CNIL fined Google 150 million euros and Facebook 60 million euros because refusing took more clicks than accepting. Banners also cover part of the screen and add scripts, so their design affects every visitor.

OK looks like this: a banner with accept and reject buttons of equal weight on the first layer, no tracking before the choice, and content still readable behind it. getReport detects the consent platform and checks for a first-layer reject option.

What a passing site looks like

  • Cookie banner reject option: passeswarning · −1.5 ptseffort S
  • No cookie banner detectedinfo onlyeffort S

Questions people ask

What is a cookie banner?

A cookie banner is a pop-up or bar that tells visitors which cookies a website uses and asks for their consent before setting non-essential ones. It usually offers accept all, reject all and settings. A consent management platform such as Cookiebot, OneTrust, Complianz or CookieYes typically runs it.

Do you need a cookie banner for CCPA?

The CCPA does not require an opt-in cookie banner like the GDPR does. It requires a clear way to opt out of the sale or sharing of personal information, usually a "Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information" link, and honouring Global Privacy Control signals. Many sites use one banner for both.

What are the cookie banner requirements?

Under EU rules: ask before setting non-essential cookies, explain their purposes in plain language, offer reject as prominently as accept on the first layer, no pre-ticked boxes, no tracking before the choice, and an easy way to change the choice later. Record each consent so you can prove it.

Does a cookie banner need a reject button?

In the EU, effectively yes. Regulators including the CNIL and the EDPB expect refusing to be as easy as accepting, which means a reject or only necessary button on the first layer, not hidden in settings. Several fines have been issued for banners without one.

Filed under Best practices. Copy is generated from the same catalogue that scores every report, so what you read here is what the report says.